| Something to keep in mind | |
|
|
| Author | Message |
|---|
GlassPrison
Age : 20 Joined : 21 Jul 2007 Posts : 2022
 | Subject: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 2:27 pm | |
| I was thinking about what Tohos said in another thread about Halloween being his favorite holiday while Christmas is his least, due to all of the commercialism. I was thinking about how commercial Halloween is too, but it's actually a religious day for groups of a certain belief. This is not directed at Tohos in any way shape or form... his comment was just a starting point for what I thought are some good things to think about: - it's funny how many people of the Christian persuasion have no problem celebrating the commercialized version of halloween and participating in the various cultural rituals of candy-giving and trick-or-treating involved without even giving a second thought to some of the more spiritual "meanings" it supposedly originally had and still has for select groups. -it's funny how some of those people above are also the first to complain about Christmas becoming commercialized, robbed from Christian theology, having Christ taken out of it and reduced to a bunch of cultural rituals of gift-giving, get togethers and the like. - If a Christian wants to celebrate halloween, he can do so without any of the supposed spiritual elements to it. If an atheist wants to celebrate Christmas he should be allowed to do the same... in peace. What good is all the sarcastic "PC" commentary? I would think that it would actually take away from your own experience of Christmas. How about just letting everyone make of the day what they will, do with the day what they will and leave it at that? ^^ And if that is too much, well then, just remember that Dec. 25th was originally a pagan celebration, and SueNC says that anything that isn't Christian is pagan, so maybe all of us non-Christians are just celebrating the pagan holiday that the day originally was.  _________________ ] |
|
 | |
Sir Shred A Lot

Age : 78 Joined : 21 Apr 2007 Posts : 1509
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 2:33 pm | |
| Basically everything you just said is what I tried to explain to some people last week...
Not people here, but people in the *real* world. |
|
 | |
Angel with Attitude The Emperor Has No Clothes

Joined : 09 Apr 2007 Posts : 2768
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 2:41 pm | |
| | Quote: | How about just letting everyone make of the day what they will, do with the day what they will and leave it at that?
|
W/o getting too deeply into it.... Agreed! _________________ only symbols can be twisted ,burned,spat on etc.NOTHING truly Holy can be desecrated.....
Courage in women is often mistaken for insanity |
|
 | |
Orion Crystal Ice Rider of the Astral Fire

Age : 23 Joined : 02 Jan 2007 Posts : 5882
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 2:46 pm | |
| If people on either side don't understand the others' POV by now, they never will, so who gives a piss. _________________ Dark motions, black eyes, and mournful lust, the wings of solitude ...I'm the hateful raven
I dream in shades of you.
 |
|
 | |
Tall Tyrion

Age : 40 Joined : 27 Jan 2007 Posts : 5683
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 2:47 pm | |
| | GlassPrison wrote: | If an atheist wants to celebrate Christmas he should be allowed to do the same... in peace. What good is all the sarcastic "PC" commentary? I would think that it would actually take away from your own experience of Christmas. How about just letting everyone make of the day what they will, do with the day what they will and leave it at that? |
I would agree if it were a matter of letting each one celebrate Saturnalia (Christmas) as (s)he saw fit. But if 95% of a community want some public display of a religious nature, why should 5% dictate it's removal? _________________ It's almost like religion is what happens when the Spirit has left the building. - Bono |
|
 | |
Angel with Attitude The Emperor Has No Clothes

Joined : 09 Apr 2007 Posts : 2768
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 2:55 pm | |
| The plastic baby Jesus...it burns us Precioussss _________________ only symbols can be twisted ,burned,spat on etc.NOTHING truly Holy can be desecrated.....
Courage in women is often mistaken for insanity |
|
 | |
GODSWIZARD Play it LOUD!!
Age : 51 Joined : 06 Jan 2007 Posts : 11691
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 2:59 pm | |
| GP said:
| Quote: | | What good is all the sarcastic "PC" commentary? |
Because "PC" is B.S. That was easy.
 _________________ "The 'farce' is strong with Obama-Wan." words of Scourge.
One of the twins: I'm the one who likes it all.... |
|
 | |
GODSWIZARD Play it LOUD!!
Age : 51 Joined : 06 Jan 2007 Posts : 11691
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 3:00 pm | |
| GP said, and then Angel said:
| Quote: |
| Quote: | How about just letting everyone make of the day what they will, do with the day what they will and leave it at that?
|
W/o getting too deeply into it.... Agreed!
|
And then I said:
Bingo.
 _________________ "The 'farce' is strong with Obama-Wan." words of Scourge.
One of the twins: I'm the one who likes it all.... |
|
 | |
Sir Shred A Lot

Age : 78 Joined : 21 Apr 2007 Posts : 1509
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 3:28 pm | |
| | Tall Tyrion wrote: |
I would agree if it were a matter of letting each one celebrate Saturnalia (Christmas) as (s)he saw fit. But if 95% of a community want some public display of a religious nature, why should 5% dictate it's removal? |
There is plenty of non-public (i.e., private) space for such a display if it's that important to a community, IMO. |
|
 | |
Tall Tyrion

Age : 40 Joined : 27 Jan 2007 Posts : 5683
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 3:31 pm | |
| That's not the point. If it really is public property, then why should the 5% dictate to the 95% on how it is used? _________________ It's almost like religion is what happens when the Spirit has left the building. - Bono |
|
 | |
GODSWIZARD Play it LOUD!!
Age : 51 Joined : 06 Jan 2007 Posts : 11691
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 3:35 pm | |
| Because the "5%" have 3 things. 1. The biggest mouths. 2. The loudest voices. 3. Sympathetic leftists in government with power to give *voice*, if you will, to their loud mouths.
 _________________ "The 'farce' is strong with Obama-Wan." words of Scourge.
One of the twins: I'm the one who likes it all.... |
|
 | |
Sir Shred A Lot

Age : 78 Joined : 21 Apr 2007 Posts : 1509
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 4:08 pm | |
| | Tall Tyrion wrote: | | That's not the point. If it really is public property, then why should the 5% dictate to the 95% on how it is used? |
I don't know... Not to nitpick too much, but I think it's important, the 5% in your scenario would be dictating how the property is "NOT used"'; they wouldn't be dictating how it is used. In other words, if the 5% were of a different religious group, they could not display something promoting their religion on that same public property.
I really don't care if my religion gets promoted on public property or not, so this doesn't matter much to me.
It sounds like you're saying that the majority religion should be able to display it's religion on public property, but are you saying the same thing about minority religions?
If not, then you're favoring one religion over another, which would be in obvious violation of the spirit of the founding fathers and the Constitution. |
|
 | |
Tall Tyrion

Age : 40 Joined : 27 Jan 2007 Posts : 5683
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 4:10 pm | |
| Bingo. 
That's why leftist policies are enacted legislatively and judicially. If put to a vote, most of this kind of thing would go down in flames. _________________ It's almost like religion is what happens when the Spirit has left the building. - Bono |
|
 | |
eye's betray the soul A Mere Peasant

Age : 30 Joined : 08 Dec 2007 Posts : 4484
 | |
 | |
scottmitchell74

Age : 34 Joined : 06 Mar 2007 Posts : 3777
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 5:50 pm | |
| | Quote: | | it burns us Precioussss |
The Elves made plastic Baby Jesus! _________________ Hey kid!
 |
|
 | |
exo

Age : 33 Joined : 06 Apr 2007 Posts : 5874
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 6:26 pm | |
| | GODSWIZARD wrote: | Because the "5%" have 3 things. 1. The biggest mouths. 2. The loudest voices. 3. Sympathetic leftists in government with power to give *voice*, if you will, to their loud mouths.
 |
Also, don't be under the perception we live in a true democracy. If that was the case, the 95% WOULD control the situation.
But we don't. We live in a representative republic. And those representatives.....well, they go back to GW's points. _________________
 |
|
 | |
eye's betray the soul A Mere Peasant

Age : 30 Joined : 08 Dec 2007 Posts : 4484
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 6:35 pm | |
| As soon as I get enough money and/or find myself in that right situation..I'll be headin' over the Atlantic Ocean. The Castles and well crafted bier need me.
But yea..Instead of the USA , we should be the USRA. _________________ Come Heaven. Come Shadows. Come crashing over me. I feel that something will have to break.. And the sky beneath - Covenant.
http://chamberofsolace.heavenforum.com/forum.htm

http://www.myspace.com/opusmajestic
 |
|
 | |
GlassPrison
Age : 20 Joined : 21 Jul 2007 Posts : 2022
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 6:38 pm | |
| I think the problem is with the 95% if they can't get organized enough to actually do something about an issue. Half-caring isn't grounds to complain on. And putting a video up on YouTube doesn't count as activism. _________________ ] |
|
 | |
eye's betray the soul A Mere Peasant

Age : 30 Joined : 08 Dec 2007 Posts : 4484
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 6:51 pm | |
| TO be honest..this country's never done anything for me in return for my allegiance and hard work and obedience to the laws. Except..
sell me out to slave labor from the South,
make things difficult for me because of not being Hispanic... ( When I was younger my parents had to lie and say I was hispanic too get me into a non-gang violent high school)... and
rape me financially on taxes, so they could provide welfare to bums and illegals.
..to mention a few things
yea..We're the greatest country on earth!.........*COugh*-Bullcrap-*Coung, Cough*.. _________________ Come Heaven. Come Shadows. Come crashing over me. I feel that something will have to break.. And the sky beneath - Covenant.
http://chamberofsolace.heavenforum.com/forum.htm

http://www.myspace.com/opusmajestic
 |
|
 | |
alldatndensum Mission Of One

Age : 38 Joined : 03 Jan 2007 Posts : 5408
 | Subject: Re: Something to keep in mind Wed Dec 12, 2007 10:15 pm | |
| To be perfectly honest, I wouldn't mind the commercialism of Christmas so much if it were just a total secular holiday. I would not mind so much if Christmas (the religious expression) and Christmas (the secular celebration) were separated, and allowed to grow/morph into whatever they will without the other. _________________

"Don't take yourself so seriously. No one else does." |
|
 | |
| Something to keep in mind | |
|