| | New SCOURGED FLESH reviews | |
|
|
| Author | Message |
|---|
Mercury
Number of posts: 49 Registration date: 2009-07-27
 | Subject: Re: New SCOURGED FLESH reviews Sat Oct 17, 2009 4:29 pm | |
| Yeah, true. maybe once I have finished the DE cd. it is going to be a scorcher! Sent the final track order to Allan last night. We are not far away from the final art either-as well as shirt stuff. I hope you all like it really fast, really dynamic and really brutal! |
|
 | |
Sutekh

Number of posts: 232 Age: 36 Registration date: 2008-07-25
 | Subject: Re: New SCOURGED FLESH reviews Sat Oct 17, 2009 5:55 pm | |
| I'm not a fan of metalcore, so I can't see that influence. I can hear the Obituary influence a little, though, and would suggest that the band is heading in a death metal direction (what I'm hearing is an intense thrash/borderline death sound, a little like Mortification's debut), but is not there yet. I will say that I'm really enjoying the album, no matter what style you call it! Aaaand... looking forward to hearing that DE, too, merc. I'm sure it's worth the wait! |
|
 | |
Mercury
Number of posts: 49 Registration date: 2009-07-27
 | Subject: Re: New SCOURGED FLESH reviews Sat Oct 17, 2009 8:12 pm | |
| Oh it ill be! Allan and Drew are already writing a follow up. I have been penning an outline for the next DE album-its going to put a cat amongst the pidgeons in the christian deathmetal scene for sure (and I think it will do very well in the secular). Rose of Sha'aron is in progress. I'll give a little bit of info. Blackmetal meets death metal (Emperor meets Nile). Very fast (280), very atmospheric-but not necessarily in a Dimmu Borgir way. And it will be tuned to 'A' which is very unusual for a blackmetal sound (traditionally more a deathmetal thing). Allan Butt is a freak! And his brother Drew is a drumming freak. Plus Phil Bloomfield who is a bass freak. Its just all freak. There will be a special guest or two hehe-but not in a tacky way. I'm pouring my soul into this-I am writing my best lyrics and going to really push the vox to the max. |
|
 | |
strangerhoncho
Number of posts: 357 Registration date: 2007-04-20
 | Subject: Re: New SCOURGED FLESH reviews Sun Oct 18, 2009 11:26 am | |
| Silly debate, of course, but I'm going to jump in on this and say the first 2 songs on myspace sound a lot more like modern metalcore or deathcore to me as well. Very groove-based and simplistic, and total metalcore vocals with that drawn-out phlegm gurgle. Carcass may have invented such vocals, but bands like Zao and others appropriated them for metalcore and they have since become the standard. Third track on myspace, Chains of Slavery, leans more to death & thrash metal, though, with its rhythms. The vocals are still 2nd wave metalcore, though. The older tracks on myspace are clearly all death metal & thrash, though, in vocals and music. The problem with defining metal genres is that they're always evolving! We have fusions and transitional forms all over the place these days, and the best bands don't stick to tradition. It's a good thing. |
|
 | |
Soundmass.com

Number of posts: 104 Registration date: 2007-06-24
 | Subject: Re: New SCOURGED FLESH reviews Sun Oct 18, 2009 12:10 pm | |
| | strangerhoncho wrote: | | Third track on myspace, Chains of Slavery, leans more to death & thrash metal, though, with its rhythms. The vocals are still 2nd wave metalcore, though. |
"Chains of Slavery" is the MySpace track that is most indicitive of the rest of the album. |
|
 | |
strangerhoncho
Number of posts: 357 Registration date: 2007-04-20
 | Subject: Re: New SCOURGED FLESH reviews Sun Oct 18, 2009 2:37 pm | |
| |
|
 | |
DaveK
Number of posts: 1 Registration date: 2009-10-20
 | Subject: Re: New SCOURGED FLESH reviews Mon Oct 19, 2009 9:05 pm | |
| | Mercury wrote: | Good sounds. Nice mix, good songs, good score!
However, I have to question 'Stefan's' knowledge of metal-Scourged Flesh sound almost nothing like the bands he was referencing. If anything SF sound like metalcore with a more thrash style song structure-not deathmetal. Can't hear Mordid Angel, Cannibal Corpse, Anglecorpse,Deicide, Nile or even Death in SF's style and sound.
Still, it is big jump from their previous releases and they have done a good job on it.
Mercury |
Okay, what I am about to say in no way reflects the opinions of any other SF member or any other band Ive been involved with. This is my own personal response and Im giving you some "true feedback". Quite regulary Mr Brown, I see you discrediting many bands and tarnishing reviews. Have you in fact looked at "Stefan's" other reviews? He does in fact know metal VERY well. SF does have similarities to the bands he was referencing. The vocals- Carcass, The guitars- Quo Vadis. Not once does he mention anything about the drums being like these bands. Yes, Quo Vadis has more technical drums, but peronally I dont like them. Im not a fan of blast beats or ultra fast kicks, so sue me. Quo Vadis has some similar melodies to the new SF album so Im not suprised by that reference. As for supposedly sounding metalcore, who gives a crap. Seriously, we simply had fun writing and recording a album and had no agenda. All of us in SF like metalcore so if that shines through, so be it. Also, trying to compare InExordium and SF is lame. 2 very different styles. Personally I dont think InExordium sound anything like Boltthrower but I wouldnt discredit a review if someone mentioned that. I really dont see the big deal about trying to lump a band into a genre. We never set out to fit into "the mould" of a genre. SF has never tried to be the biggest and best band, we play music because we love it, nothing more, nothing less. Also, I think its very disrespectful to hijack the thread and talk about your own bands. I find that a big insult as a fellow musician and quite frankly Im tired of seeing you do it on a number of occasions. Feel free to open your own thread to big note your own bands but Im pretty sure the title of this thread is "New SF reviews". Ego's are best left in the school yard dude, Im suprised theres room for your band on stage while you are there. Im sorry if this sounds too harsh. Actually, to be honest, Im not sorry. Im simply telling it how it is and Ive been pissed off for a while with how you have gone about things. And with that note, Im signing off. - Dave
 |
|
 | |
Mercury
Number of posts: 49 Registration date: 2009-07-27
 | Subject: Re: New SCOURGED FLESH reviews Tue Oct 20, 2009 4:36 am | |
| Dave, I am greatly saddened by your post. I know you have been going through a difficult time of late and that can affect how one sees and responds to things. I don't take it personally mate, feel free to give me a call and we can chat. In the meantime, i would like to respond to some of your statement which I find somewhat confusing. 1. I do not 'regularly discredit bands or their reviews, all I have done here is questioned the understanding of the reviewer, the more albums you do the more you see how unusual and varied reviewers can be. Don't believe everything you read or what everyone tells you. The measuring stick for me has always be the hardest judges, the metal heads with years and years of experience-and those who hate me for what i believe. When you win them over, then you can begin to believe that what you are doing is half decent. I would love to see you have that same experience and success to! 2.I have never discredited Scourged Flesh either-refer to my above posts and you will see that I actually praised you and in no way attacked you. I'm putting your sensitivity here down to other things and you must know that I, along with many others in the Aus christian scene are hopeful that your new album will do well. It all adds up and builds upon the work that we all do in this scene. 3. When it comes to referencing bands as influences, my preference has always been, especially in validating reviewers, an interpretation based on the whole sound of a band, not just part of their sound. Not everyone compares bands like that. Perhaps I should have clarified that earlier to avoid any misinterpretation. The scene that i play references band comparisons like that-so that is what I am used to. If that has upset you then i am saddened. 5. On the topic of metalcore. There is no judgement from me here, it is simply an observation. Some 'purists' may see metalcore as a negative, I don't and there are quite a few 'metalcore' bands that I enjoy. My point is that there will be those hardline reviewers who measure your sound based on defined genres. Once again, that is what I am used to and so are many mainstream metal reviewers in Europe and the U.S and east coast Aus. If SF sits somewhere in between then great-do your best at it and know you have friends and supporters on the East Coast who want to see you do well. 6. My comparison with InExordium and Bolthrower is only an illustration of how varied sounds can be and how varied reviewers can be-and make similar conclusions. My point is-don't believe everything you read, the variations can be unusual. 7. I won't argue about Ego. I guess when you play with Sherlocks, Bloomfields, Willmotts and co you have to be confident enough to make room on stage-a front man is supposed to be supremely confident and have a dominant presence-especially in a blackmetal band. Can this be a negative-sure, however I am fortunate enough to be playing with some of the very best who are not afraid to let me know if the 'wings' need to be clipped. Having a great wife also has that effect  Once again mate, feel free to call me or pm me. We don't need the devil to get in, especially after the excellent happening during Blackstump and the wonderful things that some bands are planning in order to promote christian metal in Australia. Your part of that mate and I want to see you do well. Regards, Mercury |
|
 | |
ultmetal

Number of posts: 3415 Registration date: 2006-12-26
 | Subject: Re: New SCOURGED FLESH reviews Tue Oct 20, 2009 6:15 am | |
| |
|
 | |
Soundmass.com

Number of posts: 104 Registration date: 2007-06-24
 | Subject: Re: New SCOURGED FLESH reviews Wed Oct 21, 2009 3:59 am | |
| Cheers Scott. Another review is in, this time receiving a score of 16/20 from Musik An Sich (Germany). The review can be found at the following link: http://musikansich.de/review.php?id=7482 |
|
 | |
Mercury
Number of posts: 49 Registration date: 2009-07-27
 | Subject: Re: New SCOURGED FLESH reviews Wed Oct 21, 2009 5:18 am | |
| |
|
 | |
mre312
Number of posts: 6 Age: 27 Registration date: 2009-04-28
 | Subject: Re: New SCOURGED FLESH reviews Wed Oct 21, 2009 8:00 pm | |
| Do a translation of it using babelfish... leads to a few amusing names... |
|
 | |
Soundmass.com

Number of posts: 104 Registration date: 2007-06-24
 | Subject: Re: New SCOURGED FLESH reviews Fri Oct 23, 2009 12:20 pm | |
| For those who are digitally inclined, SCOURGED FLESH "Welcome to the End of the World" is now available on iTunes. |
|
 | |
Soundmass.com

Number of posts: 104 Registration date: 2007-06-24
 | |
 | |
Soundmass.com

Number of posts: 104 Registration date: 2007-06-24
 | |
 | |
Sutekh

Number of posts: 232 Age: 36 Registration date: 2008-07-25
 | Subject: Re: New SCOURGED FLESH reviews Tue Nov 03, 2009 3:18 am | |
| Death metal is serious business!?! I mean.... I think he misunderstands the Aussie sense of humour somewhat. Funny stuff! |
|
 | |
| | New SCOURGED FLESH reviews | |
|